All I can say is yum! Everything we had at Mabel's Lobster Claw was delicious. Our server was super nice and friendly. The food was so good.
How has no one mentioned the fried haddock sandwiches? I've seen them on the menus, but decided only to order one at Mabel's. it was ridiculously good!
Lobster Mac and Cheese: enough said!
Husband had the seafood Newburgh, he loved it.
Oh-- and the blueberry pie-- mmm!